সোমবার, অক্টোবর ০৯, ২০১৭

ROHINGYA REFUGEE WRIT IN THE INDIAN SUPREME COURT: WRIT PETITION [CIVIL] NO.793 OF 2017, Mohammad Salimullah Versus Union of India.

See our main Facebook page or blog for the Writ for the text of the Writ Petition, the Orders of the Court and more.

SUR REJOINDER ON BEHALF OF UNION OF INDIA dated 3rd October 2017: (The following is taken from www.livelaw.in, retrieved on 08.10.2017):
x
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[ CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION ]
WRIT PETITION [CIVIL] NO.793 OF 2017
In the matter of
Mohammad Salimullah & Anr. ... Petitioners
Versus
Union of India & ors. ...Respondents
SUR REJOINDER ON BEHALF OF UNION OF INDIA
I, Mukesh Mittal s/o Shri V.P. Mittal, Joint Secretary [Foreigners] in the Ministry of Home Affairs, aged about 57 years having my office at National Stadium, Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi, do hereby solemnly affirm and state as under:
1. I am functioning as Joint Secretary [Foreigners] in the Ministry of Home Affairs, Union of India. In my official capacity and being duly authorised and being fully conversant with the facts and circumstances of the subject matter of the writ petition I am filing this sur-rejoinder. I state and submit that I have gone through, perused and understood the relevant records and material with respect to the subject matter of the petition based upon which I am filing this Sur Rejoinder to place the following legal as well as factual position for kind consideration of this Hon’ble Court.
2. I state that the Answering Respondent is served with an Affidavit in Rejoinder filed by the Petitioner to the Affidavit in Reply filed by the Answering Respondent. I crave leave to file this affidavit in Sur-Rejoinder.
3. At the very outset, I very respectfully reiterate the respectful submissions made in the counter affidavit already filed to the effect that the subject matter of the petition would be essentially a core executive function in the realm of policy making for the country viz. take decision with respect to dealing with illegal immigrants. Such decisions are taken on a case to case basis and are based upon several facts, situations and considerations. The considerations, including diplomatic considerations, internal security considerations, potential demographic changes, possibility of law and order, sharing of national resources, sustainability of an additional burden on the resources of the country etc. are some of the considerations which are kept in mind by the executive which this Hon’ble Court would not go into, re-evaluate and based upon such re-evaluation would substitute its satisfaction in place of the satisfaction reached by the executive as a part of administrative governance.
4. I very respectfully pray that this question of the maintainability of the petition, the extent of power of judicial review, if any, and availability of fundamental rights to the petitioners [who are admittedly illegal immigrants] so as to invoke Article 32 of the Constitution of India may be addressed and decided first before examining the petition on merits.
I hereby reiterate the contents of my Affidavit in Reply and deny all facts stated in the Rejoinder under reply except those which are specifically and unequivocally admitted by me hereunder.
5. I respectfully submit that by way of this Sur-Rejoinder, I am dealing with the issues raised therein and, therefore, not responding to the rejoinder parawise. I, however, deny all the facts stated, contentions raised and grounds submitted except those specifically admitted by me. I respectfully submit that my not dealing with the petition para-wise may not be treated as my having admitted the truthfulness or otherwise of any of the contents thereon.
6. I state and submit that broadly the rejoinder covers three issues :
(i) The issues raised based upon the Government of India’s Notification dated 7.9.2015;
(ii) The issue emanating from the Circular dated 8.8.2017 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs;
(iii) The issues based upon certain Declaration and / or other international instruments and its interpretation given by the Petitioner.
7. I state and submit that as pointed out hereinabove, any administrative decision taken by the executive with respect to illegal immigrants in question in each case depends upon the variety reasons, empirical data, facts, potential danger to internal security, the number of illegal immigrants involved, disturbances in the social fabric of the country or any particular part thereof, possibility of law and order problem arising in the country or any part thereof, demographic changes and its extent etc. Considering the very nature of such a decision which are to be taken on a case to case basis, there cannot be any comparison or claim of discrimination based upon some earlier decision taken with respect to one set of illegal immigrants vis-à- vis another set of illegal immigrants.
The comparison, therefore, between the factors which went into consideration of the administrative decision making culminating into the Notifications dated 7.9.2015 and 18.7.2016 cannot be compared with the decision with respect to Rohingyas who are about 40,000 approximately in number, having other options and most disturbingly the continuing of a systematic influx of illegal immigrants in an organised manner into India through agents and touts.
At the cost of repetition, it may be pointed out that illegal influx of Rohingyas, in substantially significant numbers, have started into the territory of India since 2012-13 and the Central Government has contemporaneous inputs from security agencies and other authentic material indicating linkages of some of the unauthorised Rohingya immigrants with Pakistan based and other terror organisations and similar organisations operating in other countries. Over and above the said serious security concerns already in existence, the more disturbing part is that there is an organised and systematic influx of illegal immigrants from Myanmar through agents and touts facilitating illegal and unauthorised entry of immigrant Rohingyas into India.
It is observed that some Rohingyas are indulging in illegal / anti national activities i.e. mobilization of funds through hundi/hawala channels, procuring fake/fabricated Indian identity documents for other Rohingyas and also indulging in human trafficking. They are also using their illegal network for illegal entry of others in India. Many of them have managed to acquire fake/fraudulently obtained Indian identity documents i.e. PAN Card and voter cards. It is also found that some of the Rohingyas figure in the suspected sinister designs of ISI/ISIS and other extremists groups who want to achieve their ulterior motives in India including that of flaring up communal and sectarian violence in sensitive areas of the country. The fragile north-eastern corridor may become further destabilised in case of stridency of Rohingya militancy, which the Central Government has found to be growing, if permitted to continue. There is also a serious potential and possibility of eruption of violence against the Buddhists who are Indian citizens who stay on Indian soil, by the radicalized Rohingyas. Some of the Rohingyas with militant background are also found to be very active in Jammu, Delhi, Hyderabad and Mewat, and have been identified as having a very serious and potential threat to the internal/national security of India.
Considering the fact situation in the present case, any comparison with any past decision is misconceived.
The Government takes the decision about the actions to be taken “in accordance with the law” keeping several factors into consideration including the aforesaid facts which are based upon the contemporaneous inputs and authenticated material and in the best interest of the country.
Such decision are an essential part of core executive function of the executive while discharging its duties under the constitution.
In light of the what is sated in the earlier Affidavit and what is stated hereinabove, the Government of India was not only justified but was duty-bound to issue the Circular dated 8.8.2017 with a view to ensure its primary obligation to protect the fundamental rights of its own citizens.
8. I respectfully submit that so far as the contentions based upon the Declarations / Resolutions / international instruments and some individual views expressed by the Indian representatives are concerned, the said contentions are devoid of any merits.
India, as a sovereign State, is fully conscious, aware and responsible about its obligations emanating from various international instruments which deal with its interaction globally and its actions domestically. As a sovereign State, India will always honour such obligations which are binding obligations.
Having said that it is reiterated that India is not a signatory to United Nation Convention of 1951 and the Protocol of 1967 issued thereunder.
The said Convention / Protocol is, therefore, not binding upon India and no other Declaration / Resolution / Convention / international treaty or instrument of any kind is in force which prohibits India, as a sovereign nation, to exercise its right of deporting illegal immigrants in accordance with laws of India and thereby protecting the fundamental rights of its own citizens more particularly in the interest of national security.
9. I state and submit that reliance placed upon the New York Declaration, 2016, Declaration of Territorial Asylum, Universal Declaration on Human Rights etc. is misplaced since these Declarations are mere recommendations and aims at reminding, reinforcing, and ensuring implementation of obligations specifically assumed under legally binding international instruments by States that become party to them. They, at the most, seeks to encourage non-party States to become party to such instruments and accept the obligations flowing from them. The obligations of non-refoulement is essentially covered by the provisions of the 1951 Refugee Convention, to which India is not a party. It is thus clear that reliance upon any other Declarations / Resolutions etc. is not only misplaced but does not confer any legally enforceable rights either upon the petitioners or anyone else which can justify prayers for issuance of a writ of this Hon'ble Court under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.
10. I respectfully submit that similarly though India is a party to the Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989, this is not a Convention under which refugees’ status and non refoulement are addressed. As pointed out hereinabove, these matters are regulated essentially under the provisions of 1951 Refugee Convention to which India is not a party.
11. I respectfully state and submit that reference to New York Declaration for Refugees and Migrants, 2016, as made in para 11 of the Rejoinder, is also misplaced. The main thrust of this instrument is to have a global impact on matters relating to refugees and migrants. The said instrument is not a legally binding instrument which fact is recognized in para 21 and 65 of the said Declaration itself.
It is submitted that the remarks made by the Indian representatives or general views expressed by them at some Symposium on World Humanitarian Summit or elsewhere cannot be elevated to the level of a legally binding document based upon which a writ of this Hon’ble Court can be prayed for. It is submitted that India’s participation at discussions in the global summits or otherwise in which issues pertaining to refugees are being discussed, cannot be construed as India having accepted any binding legal obligation and having given up its right to act as per its laws with illegal immigrants and thereby abdicating its obligation of protecting fundamental rights of its own citizens. There is, obviously, a reason why there is a well laid down process and procedure in favour of signature and ratification of each of the international conventions by various States.
There cannot be any binding obligation either.
The above referred facts, if read with the Rejoinder would show that while India is a party to some international conventions pertaining to human rights / refugees, there is no binding legal obligation on Government of India with respect of non-refoulement flowing from any binding international instrument.
12. So far as reference to notice issued by the National Commission for Human Rights is concerned, the Government of India has placed its facts before the said Commission by way of reply.
13. I submit that the illegal immigrants would not get and cannot claim any of the fundamental rights which are otherwise available to non-citizens as the term “non-citizens” would necessarily mean persons, not citizens of India, is in India on a valid travel document. The framers of the Constitution of India would not have envisaged a situation where thousands and thousands of people would be flowing into this country entering illegally without any valid travel documents and start claiming fundamental rights as non-citizens.
14. I respectfully submit that rest of the averments made in the Rejoinder are general in nature, reiteration of already stated contentions, some statements made by some individuals etc. It is submitted that the petitioners cannot pray for a writ of this Hon'ble Court based upon such statements and news reports.
DEPONENT
VERIFICATION
Verified and signed on this 3rd day of October, 2017. That contents of para 1 to 14 of the above sur-rejoinder is true and correct to my knowledge and belief and nothing material has been concealed therefrom.
DEPONENT
Disclaimer:

The above information is for information purposes only. The information and commentary contained herein do not amount to, and are not intended as, legal advice to any person on a specific case or matter, and should not be relied on for this purpose.

We are not responsible for any information on this page which contains materials prepared by third parties or for information contained on linked sites or for any reliance that may be placed upon their contents.

রবিবার, অক্টোবর ০৮, ২০১৭

ROHINGYA REFUGEE WRIT IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, WRIT PETITION [CIVIL] NO.793 OF 2017, Mohammad Salimullah & Another, Versus, Union of India & Others

Synopsis and full text of the Writ Petition provided by the ‘Sab Media Software Services Private Limited’ at www.barandbench.com (27 pages) available at (Please see disclaimer below): rohingya final writ petition - Bar & Bench
Daily Order, Supreme Court of India
Writ Petition (Civil) No.793/2017

Date : 01-09-2017 Date : 11-09-2017 Date : 03-10-2017 http://supremecourtofindia.nic.in/s... For Petitioner(s): 03.10.2017 A Surrejoinder was filed on behalf of the Union of India. The full text of the surrejoinder is available at www.livelaw.in, retrieved on 08.10.2017); alternatively at our blog, or Facebook page. Disclaimer: The above information is for information purposes only. The information and commentary contained herein do not amount to, and are not intended as, legal advice to any person on a specific case or matter, and should not be relied on for this purpose. We are not responsible for any information on this page which contains materials prepared by third parties or for information contained on linked sites or for any reliance that may be placed upon their contents.
x

‘(T)aken on Board’ for hearing on mentioning on 01-09-2017
Dates of Hearing : 03-10-2017; 18-09-2017’; 11-09-2017; 04-09-2017; 01-09-2017


WITH W.P.(C) NO.877/2017
(With appln.(s) for intervention and permission to appear and argue in person)
W.P.(C) NO.870/2017
W.P.(C) NO.886/2017
W.P.(C) NO.916/2017

Full text of this and other orders available at: http://supremecourtofindia.nic.in/d...


These petitions were called on for hearing today.

CORAM :
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.M. KHANWILKAR
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE D.Y. CHANDRACHUD


Mr. Fali S. Nariman, Sr. Adv. ,Mr. S.C. Sharma, Adv., Mr. Prashant Bhushan, AOR, Ms. Cheryl D'souza, Adv., Ms. Amiy Shukla, Adv., Mr. Shakti Vardhan, Adv., Ms. Aastha Shah, Adv., WP(C) 877/17 Mr. J.P. Dhanda, AOR Ms. Raj Rani Dhanda, Adv. Mr. Vineet Dhanda, Adv. Mr. N.A. Usmani, Adv. Mr. Gopi Chand, Adv.

WP(C) 870/17 Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Sr. Adv. Mr. Fazal Abdali, Adv. Mr. Satya Mitra, Adv.

WP(C) 793/2017 2 WP(C) 886/17 Ms. Sujeeta Srivastava, AOR

WP(C) 916/17 Mr. Kalyan Bandopadhyay, Sr. Adv. Mr. Kunal Chatterji, Adv. Ms. Maitrayee Banerjee, Adv.

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R

Heard in-part.

Put up for further hearing at 2 p.m. on 13th October, 2017.

“Mr. S.C. Sharma, learned counsel assisting Mr. Fali S. Nariman, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner shall make a compilation of all the documents and the notifications relied upon by the petitioners. Mr. Tushar Mehta, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India shall also file a compilation of all the documents containing international conventions, treaties and other necessary documents”.





শনিবার, সেপ্টেম্বর ৩০, ২০১৭

Hazrat Shah Jalal (R) – ‘Shāh Jalāl ad-Dīn al-Mujarrad al-Naqshbandi’ - A Literature Review

Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim

Project name: Hazrat Shah Jalal (R) – ‘Shāh Jalāl ad-Dīn al-Mujarrad al-Naqshbandi’ - A Literature Review

Project Start Date: 28.09.2017

Project Objective: Ascertaining an evidence based account of Shāh Jalāl ad-Dīn al-Mujarrad al-Naqshbandi (Hazrat Shah Jalal) (R) of Sylhet’s life and work.

Literature:

1. Shah Jalal (R), Banglapedia entry - the National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh, http://en.banglapedia.org/index.php?title=Shah_Jalal_(R), accessed on 28.09.2017, “(T)his page was last modified on 7 April 2015, at 12:45”.

Finds:

His full name is Shaikh Jalaluddin[1].

“Shah Jalal's name is associated with the Muslim conquest of Sylhet. Tradition goes that a Hindu king named Gaur Govinda ruled the Sylhet area. Burhanuddin, a Muslim who lived in the territory under his control once sacrificed a cow to celebrate the birth of his son. But a kite snatched a piece of flesh of the slaughtered cow and it fell from its beak on the house of a Brahmin. According to another tradition, the piece of flesh fell on the temple of the king himself, which he took as a great offence. At the order of the king, Burhanuddin's hands were said to have been cut off and his son killed. Burhanuddin went to gaur and submitted a prayer to Sultan shamsuddin firuz shah for justice from him. The sultan accordingly sent an army under the command of his nephew Sikandar Khan Ghazi, who was however, defeated twice by Gaur Govinda. The sultan then ordered his sipahxalar (armed forces chief) Nasiruddin to lead the war. During the same time Shah Jalal (R) with his 360 followers reached Bengal and joined the Muslim army in the Sylhet campaign. This time the Muslim army won, Gaur Govinda fled the country and Sylhet came under Muslim rule”[2].

“Epigraphic and literary sources also attest the fact of the conquest of Sylhet during Shamsuddin Firuz Shah's rule and of the involvement of Shah Jalal (R) in the process”[3].

“ibn batuta visited Bengal when Sultan fakhruddin mubarak shah was ruling at Sonargaon (1338-1349 AD). He met Shah Jalal (R) in the latter's khanqah and stayed three days there in 1346 AD. Ibn Batuta, however, wrongly recorded the name of the saint as Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R). Scholars have established that Ibn Batuta's 'Tabrizi' is a mistake for 'Kuniyayi', the epithet for Shah Jalal (R)”[4].

“The earliest and most acceptable source of information about the first Muslim conquest of Sylhet and the advent of Islam in the area is a Persian inscription of 918 AH/1512 AD issued in the reign of Sultan Alauddin husain shah (1494-1519 AD). According to the inscription, Sylhet was first conquered by Sikandar Shah Ghazi in 703 AH/1303 AD in the reign of Shamsuddin Firuz Shah. The inscription was dedicated to the sacred memory of Shaikh Jalal Mujarrad ibn Muhammad. Though the inscription was issued after a little more than two hundred years of the event, it seems to have the accurate historical dates”[5].

“An account of the conquest of Sylhet by Shah Jalal (R) and his companions is found in the Gulzar-i-Abrar of Ghausi, written in 1613 AD. It is based on the earlier work Sharh-i-Nuzhat-ul-Arwah by Shaikh Ali Sher, a descendant of Shaikh Nurul Huda Abul Karamat, who was a companion of Shah Jalal (R) who took part in the conquest of Sylhet. According to this source, Shaikh Jalaluddin Mujarrad, a khalifah of Sultan Syed Ahmed Yesvi, was born in Turkistan and had settled in Sylhet. With the permission of the Pir, he came to India with 700 companions to take part in jihad (holy war). He reached Bengal with 360 of his companions. They fought against Raja Gaur Govinda of Sylhet who fled and the country around Sylhet fell into the hands of the victors. Shah Jalal (R) divided the conquered lands among his followers, permitted them to get married, but he himself, however, remained a celibate. This source gives the credit for conquering Sylhet to Shah Jalal (R) and his followers, and has no reference to any reigning king or his generals”[6].

“Nasiruddin Haidar wrote a biography of Shah Jalal (R) in Persian in 1860. The author claims that in writing the book titled Suhail-i-Yaman, he used two Persian manuscripts such as Risalat written by Muhiuddim Khadim in 1711 AD and Rauzat-us-Salatin written by an unknown author in 1721 AD. Both the manuscripts were kept preserved in the dargah of the saint. Shah Jalal's father, Muhammad, was a sufi of Yamen. Shah Jalal (R) lost his parents in his childhood and was brought up by his maternal uncle Sayyid Ahamd Kabir Suhrawardy, a great saint. After completion of formal education, Shah Jalal (R) received spiritual lessons from his uncle. It is said that Kabir gave him a handful of earth and instructed him to go to India for preaching Islam. Shah Jalal (R) was told to find the sacred place of India where the earth was of the colour and smell similar to the earth given to him and should pass the rest of his life there in prayer and meditation. On his way to India, Shah Jalal (R) met Shakh Nizamuddin Auliya at Delhi who gave him a pair of pigeons of a special species, which, according to folk belief is found still today in the dargah of Shah Jalal (R) in Sylhet and some other places of Bengal. So advised, Shah Jalal (R) moved to Bengal. It so happened that during this time, the army of Sultan Shamsuddin Firuz Shah was fighting against King Gaur Govinda of Sylhet. Shah Jalal (R) and his followers joined the battle. The biography of Shah Jalal (R) gives description of how Sylhet was conquered, as well as of some miraculous events that demonstrate the spiritual powers of the saint, which were considered for the victory more important than the prowess of the army”[7].

“Although Suhail-i-Yaman is a relatively recent book written by using both facts and hearsay, it was for sometime looked upon as a standard biography of Hazrat Shah Jalal (R). The book says that the saint came from Yemen (of the Arab peninsula), but this has been proved wrong. An inscription discovered in Sylhet in 1873 categorically indicates that Shah Jalal (R) was a Kuniyayi, ie, he came from Kuniya, a township in Turkey. In the Gulzar-i-Abrar of Ghausi he is called Turkistani.
There are every reasons to believe that Shah Jalal (R) came from Turkey and not from Yemen. Another inscription issued in honour of Shaikh-ul-Mashaikh Makhdum Shaikh Jalal Mujarrad bin Muhammad records that Sylhet was first conquered by Sikandar Khan Ghazi in the reign of Sultan Firuz Shah in 703 AH/1303 AD. This is also supported by Gulzar-i-Abrar”[8].

“In his travel accounts, Ibn Batuta described that Shah Jalal (R) was a great saint of hoary age and a dervish with exceptional spiritual powers. Ibn Batuta learnt that the saint had met Caliph al-Mustasim Billah at Baghdad, and that he was there at the time of the Caliph's assassination. The companions of Shah Jalal (R) later told Ibn Batuta that the saint died at the age of one hundred and fifty and that he observed fasting in almost all the days of a year. He also performed namaz throughout the night. He was thin, tall and scantily bearded”[9].

“Ibn Batuta also described some events that demonstrate the spiritual powers of the saint and noted that he had got the message of his death in the following year at Beijing. Recent studies show that Ibn Batuta visited Bengal in 1345-46 AD, which means, Shah Jalal (R) died in 1347”[10].

“Shah Jalal (R) was a disciple of Sayyid Ahmad Yesvi and belonged to the Naqshbandiya order of the sufis. His preceptor and fellow friends lived in agony and suspense in the days of turmoil following the Mongol invasion in Turkey”[11].

“Ibn Batuta's statement that he had met Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R) has become a subject of controversy. Some modern scholars believe that both the Jalals (Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R) and Shah Jalal (R) of Sylhet) are one and the same person, which they were not, according to recent studies. However, both of them were great saints, and had great influence on the people of Bengal. They lived and worked at different places and different times. Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R) lived in Pandua and Deotala of Maldah (West Bengal), but Shah Jalal (R) lived in Sylhet (East Bengal). Tabrizi's period was at least a century earlier than that of Shah Jalal (R) of Sylhet. The former was a contemporary of Sultan Shamsuddin iltutmish (died 1236 AD), Shaikh Qutbuddin Bakhtiyar Kaki of Delhi (died 1235 AD) and Shaikh Bahauddin Zakariya of Multan (died 1262). According to Hagiologists, Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R) died in 1226, or 1244 AD and, even if the later date is considered correct, he died one hundred three years before the death of Shah Jalal (R) of Sylhet”[12].

“Bibliography HAR Gibb, Ibn Battuta: Travels in Asia and Africa, London 1928; 'Gulzar-i-Abrar of Ghausi', Journal of the Asiatic Society of Pakistan, II, 1959;
ME Haq, A History of Sufism in Bengal, Dhaka 1975; A Karim, Social History of the Muslim in Bengal, (2nd ed), Chittagong 1985”[13].

2. Literature:

Shah Jalal, Wikipedia entry, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Jalal,[14] accessed on 28.09.2017.

Finds:

“Shāh Jalāl ad-Dīn al-Mujarrad al-Naqshbandi (Arabic: شاه جلال الدين المجرد النقشبندي‎‎), popularly known as Hazrat Shah Jalal (Arabic: شاه جلال‎‎, Bengali: শাহ জালাল, Sylheti: ꠡꠣꠢ ꠎꠣꠟꠣꠟ) (1271 CE – 15 March 1346 CE), is a celebrated Sufi Muslim figure in Bengal”[15].

“According to a tablet inscription found in Amberkhana, he arrived at Sylhet in 1303 CE”.[1][16]

“His biography was first recorded in the mid 16th century by a certain Shaikh 'Ali (d. 1562), a descendant of one of Shah Jalal's companions. Thus there is a gap of several centuries between the life of the saint and that of his earliest biographer[17]. According to this account, Shah Jalal had been born in Turkestan, where he became a spiritual disciple of Saiyid Ahmad Yasawi, one of the founders of the Central Asian Sufi tradition.[2] Therefore, although his existence is not debated, much of his life story is debated”[18].

“Early life and education[edit]
Born Jalāl ad-Dīn bin Mahmoud and became a makhdoom, teacher of Sunnah and, for performing prayers in solitary milieu and leading a secluded life as an ascetic, al Mujarrad was post fixed to his name. He was conferred with the title of Shaykh-ul-Mashāykh (Great Scholar). Shah Jalal's date and place of birth is not certain. Various traditions and historical documents differ. A number of scholars have claimed that he was born in 1271 CE in Konya in modern-day Turkey (then in the Sultanate of Rûm) and later moved to Yemen either as a child or adult while many believe he was born in a village called Kaninah in Hadhramaut, Yemen. His mother, Syeda Hasina Fatimah, and his father, Mahmoud bin Mohammed bin Ibrahim, were descendants of Hashemite dynasty of Quraysh of Mecca.[3] His father was a Muslim cleric, who was a contemporary of the Persian poet and Sufi mystic, Jalal ad-Din Muhammad Rumi. Shah Jalal was educated and raised by his maternal uncle Syed Ahmed Kabir in Mecca. He excelled in his studies; became a hafiz and mastered fiqh. He achieved spiritual perfection (Kamaliyyat) after 30 years of study, practice and meditation.[4][19]”

“Travel to India[edit]
According to legend, one day his uncle, Sheikh Kabir gave Shah Jalal a handful of soil and asked him to travel to India. He instructed him to choose to settle and propagate Islam in any place in India where the soil exactly matches that which he gave him in smell and colour.[5] Shah Jalal journeyed eastward and reached India in c. 1300, where he met many great scholars and Sufi mystics.[5][20]”

“Later life[edit]
During the later stages of his life, Shah Jalal devoted himself to propagating Islam. Shah Jalal became so renowned that the famous traveller Ibn Battuta, then in Satgaon,[6] made a one-month journey through the mountains of Kamarupa north-east of Sylhet to meet him.[7] On his way to Sylhet via Habung, Ibn Batuta was greeted by several of Shah Jalal's disciples who had come to assist him on his journey many days before he had arrived. At the meeting in 1345 CE, Ibn Batuta noted that Shah Jalal was tall and lean, fair in complexion and lived by the mosque in a cave, where his only item of value was a goat he kept for milk, butter, and yogurt. He observed that the companions of the Shah Jalal were foreign and known for their strength and bravery. He also mentions that many people would visit the Shah to seek guidance.[8][21]”

“The meeting between Ibn Batuta and Shah Jalal is described in his Arabic travelogue, Rihla (The Journey). Amir Khusrau also gives an account of Shah Jalal's conquest of Sylhet in his book Afdalul Hawaade. Even today in Hadramaut, Yemen, Shah Jalal's name is established in folklore.[9]
The exact date of his death is debated, but he is reported by Ibn Batuta to have died on 20 Dhul Qadah 746 AH (15 March 1346 CE).[10] He left behind no descendants and was buried in Sylhet in his dargah (tomb), which is located in a neighbourhood now known as Dargah Mahalla:
Where he lies, a soul eternal, The much-loved awliya of Allah, Hazrat Shah Jalal.[11]।[22]“

“References[edit]
  1. Ahmed, Shamsuddin, Inscription of Bengal, vol. iv, Dhaka (1960), p 25
  2. Eaton, Richard M. (1993). The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204–1760 (PDF). Berkeley: University of California Press.
  3.  Rahman, M. F., Hazrat Shah Jalal and 360 Awliya, Deshkaal Publications, Sylhet, 1992, p.12-13
  4.  Islam in South Asia in practice source of shuhel-e-yamani By Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published by – Princeton universiti press, 2009. Page 385 [1]
  5. Karim, Abdul (2012). "Shah Jalal (R)". In Islam, Sirajul; Jamal, Ahmed A. Banglapedia: National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh (Second ed.). Asiatic Society of Bangladesh.
  6.  Hazrat Shah Jalal O Sylhet er Itihas by Syed Mujtaba Ali, re-published by Utsa Prakashan, Dhaka, 1988, p.60
  7.  Rihla 9, 1344
  8.  Islam in South Asia in practice By – Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published – Princeton university press Uk 2009, Page 383 – 385.
  9.  The rise of Islam and the Bengal frontier, 1204–1760, By Richard Maxwell Eaton, Published by – university of california press, page 76
  10.  Rahman, M. F., Hazrat Shah Jalal and 360 Awliya, p.13, Deshkaal Publications, Sylhet, 1992
  11.  Ziaul Haque, Md., Hazrat Shah Jalal (R.A): An Epic, p.114, Choitonno Publication, Sylhet, 2015
  12. Systems, Cognitive (2012-04-08). "The seven golden chains of Shaykh Muhammad Siraj ad-Din Naqshbandi (d.1915)". Ghaffari. Retrieved 2017-07-09.
  13. Islam in South Asia in practice, By Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published by Princeton universiti press.
External links[edit]
3. Literature:

Shaykh Shah Jalal, http://www.haqislam.org/biographies/shah-jalal.htm, accessed on 28.09.2017.

Finds:

“His full name is Shaykh-ul Mashaek Mokhdum Shaykh Shah Jalal Mozorrodh Bin Muhammed. His father was the contemporary of Maulana Jalaluddin Rumi. Losing his parents early in his life he was brought up by his maternal uncle who was also a pious saint. After completing his education, his uncle gave him a handful of earth and told him to travel to a land, in Hindustan, where earth of the same colour can be found. There he should settle down and establish the religion of Islam.
In the course of his journey he met Khwaja Gharibnawaz Moinuddin Hasan Chisty and Shaykh Nizam ud din Auliya. After a while he reached Sylhet, Bengal where he found a Shaykh, Burhan ud din was being persecuted by Raja Gaur Govinda, the king of the Sylhet. Shaykh Shah Jalal and his travelling party of 300 plus auliyas joined the army which had been sent by the Sultan of Gaur against the King. Alhumdulillah, they were able to defeat the King despite two previous failed attempts.

After the conquest Shaykh Shah Jalal found a match for the earth his uncle had given him and he settled in Sylhet and remained there until his death. He and his disciples travelled as far as Mymensingh and Dhaka to preach the message of Islam.
Ibn Battutah who met Shaykh Shah Jalal in Sylhet says of him: 'he was numbered among the principal saints, and was one of the most singular of men. He had done many noteworthy acts, and wrought many celebrated miracles. He used to remain standing (in prayer) all night. The inhabitants of these mountains received Islam from his hands, and it was for this reason that he stayed among them.'
Ibn Battutah also narrates several miracles of the saint, and reports the date of his death as 1347”[24].

4. Literature:

Waines, David, The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta - uncommon tales of a medieval adventurer. Publisher: University Of Chicago Press (July 15, 2010)[25].

Finds:
“He sought permission to leave and the next sea stage of his travels is laconically expressed thus: ‘I left and we were at sea for forty-three days and then reached the country of Bengal.’[26]”

“Bengal detained him long enough to make a one-month trip into the mountains of Assam to meet a famous holy man, Jalal al-Din al-Tabrizi. Upon his return down river to the port city of Sunarkawan (Sonargaon), he found a junk bound for Sumatra (al-Jawa) and embarked upon it for a voyage of 40 days”[27].

“The final meeting with Burhan al-Din in China involved a confused and bizarre tale of apparent coincidences, resolved of course by the various pieces falling into place by an act of grace (karama). Ibn Battuta had set out to meet an aged saint in the mountains of Bengal. His arrival was foretold by the saint who instructed some companions to meet the Moroccan traveller, which they did, two days distant from the saint’s retreat. At their first meeting Ibn Battuta was struck by the saint’s attire, a goat-hair garment he had worn especially to greet his guest. Reading the covetous look on Ibn Battuta’s face, the saint gave him the cloak and his skull cap. Indeed, he had privately informed his companions beforehand that the Moroccan would desire the garment, that an infidel governor would then relieve him of it and, lo! he would give it to Burhan al-Din for whom it was originally intended. Much later, when Ibn Battuta had reached China, he was spotted wearing the goat-hair garment by a government minister who presented him to the local governor. He admired the garment and took it in exchange for ten robes of honour, a fully caparisoned horse and money.
The following year Ibn Battuta was in the Chinese capital and sought out Burhan al-Din in his hospice. He found him reading and wearing an identical goat-hair cloak! Ibn Battuta’s amazement was doubled when Burhan al-Din showed him a letter from his spiritual brother in Bengal advising him that the garment would reach him by such and such a route, every detail of which occurred precisely as Ibn Battuta had experienced it and was able to verify”[28].


30.09.2017

5. Literature:

Ibn Batuta, 1304–1377, [Tuhfat al-nuzzar fi ghara'ib al-amsar wa-'aja'ib al-asfar, English, Selections], The travels of Ibn Battuta in the Near East, Asia and Africa 1325–1354. Translated and edited by Samuel Lee, DOVER PUBLICATIONS, INC., Mineola, New York, 2004.

Finds:
“The Vizier[29] then furnished me with provisions, and I sailed form Bengal, which is an extensive and plentiful country. I never saw a country in which provisions were so cheap. I there saw one of the religious of the west, who told me, that he had bought provisions for himself and his family for a whole year with eight dirhems. The first town I entered here was nSad-kāwān,1 which is large and situated on the sea-shore.

The king of Bengal was at this time of Fakhr Oddīn : he was an eminent man, kind to strangers and persons of the Sūfī persuasion : but I did not present myself to him, nor did I see him, because he was opposed to the Emperor, and was then in open rebellion against him. From pSadkāwān I travelled for the mountains of qKāmrū, which are at the distance of one month from this place. These are extensive mountains, and they join the rmountains of Thibet, where there are musk gazelles. The inhabitants of these mountains are, like the Turks, famous for their attention to smagic. My object in visiting these mountains was, to meet one of the saints, namely, the Sheikh tJalāl Oddīn of Tebrīz. This Sheikh was one of the greatest saints, and one of those singular individuals who had the power of working great and notable miracles. He had also lived to a remarkably great age. He told me, that he had seen uEl Mostaasim the Calif in Bagdad: and his companions told me afterwards that he died at the age of one hundred and fifty years; that he fasted through a space of about forty years, never breaking his fast till he had fasted throughout ten successive days. He had a cow, on the milk of which he usually breakfasted; and his practice was to sit up all night. It was by his means that the people of these mountains became Mohammedans; and on this account it was, that he resided among them. One of his companions told me, that on the day before his death he invited them all to come to him; he then said to them: To-morrow I depart from you, Deo volente, and my vicegerent with you is God besides whom there is no other God. When the evening of the following day had arrived, and he had performed the last prostration of the evening prayer, he was taken by God. On the side of the cave in which he had resided was found a grave ready dug, and by it a winding sheet and burial spices. The people then washed and buried him in them, and said their prayers over him. When I was on my journey to see this Sheikh, four of his companions met me at the distance of two days, and told me, that the Sheikh had said to the Fakeers who were with them, A western religious traveller is coming to you : go out and meet him. It was, said they, by the order of the Sheikh that we came to you; notwithstanding the fact, that he had no knowledge whatever of my circumstances, except what he had by divine revelation. I went with them accordingly to his cell without the cave, near which there was no building whatever. The people of this country are partly Mohammedans, and partly infidels; both of whom visit the Sheikh and bring valuable presents. On these the Fakeers, and other persons who arrive here, subsist. As for the Sheikh himself, he confines himself to the milk of his cow, as already mentioned. When I presented myself to him, he arose and embraced me. He then asked me of my country and travels, of which I informed him. He then said to the Fakeers: Treat him honourably. They accordingly carried me to the cell, and kept me as their guest for three days. On the day I presented myself to the Sheikh he had on a religious xgarment, made of fine goat’s hair. I was astonished at it, and said to myself, I wish the Sheikh would give it me. When I went in to bid him farewell, he arose and went to the side of the cave, took off the goat’s hair garment, as well as the fillet of his head and his sleeves, and put them on me.

The Fakeers then told me, that it was not his practice to put on this garment: and that he had put it on only on the occasion of my coming, for he had said to them: This garment will be wished for by a Mogrebine; but an infidel king shall take it from him, and shall give it to our brother yBorhān Oddīn of Sāgirj, whose it is, and for whose use it has been made. When I was told this by the Fakeers, I said: As I have a blessing from the Sheikh, and as he has clothed me with his own clothes, I will never enter with them into the presence of any king either infidel or Moslem.

After this I left the Sheikh. It happened, however, after a considerable time, that I entered the country of China, and went as far as the city of zKhansā. Upon a certain occasion, when my companions had all left me on account of the press of the multitude, and I had this garment on, and was on the road, I met the Vizier with a large body. He happened to cast his eyes upon me, and called me to him. He then took me by the hand, and asked me why I had come to this country; nor did he leave me until we came to the King’s palace. I wished to go, but he would not allow me to do so, but took me in to the King, who interrogated me about the Mohammedan sovereigns; to all which I gave answers. He then cast his eyes upon the garment, and began to praise it, and said to the Vizier: Take it off him. To this I could offer no resistance, so he took it; but ordered me ten dresses of honour, and a horse with its furniture, and money for my necessities. This changed my mind. I then called to mind the words of the Sheikh, that an infidel king should take it; and my wonder was increased.

After a year had elapsed, I entered the palace of the King of China at aKhān Bālik,2 my object was to visit the cell of the Sheikh Borhān Oddīn of Sāgirj. I did so, and found him reading, and the very goat’s-hair garment I have been mentioning was on him. I was surprised at this, and was turning the garment over in my hand, when he said, Why do you turn the garment over, do you know it? I said, I do; it is the garment which the King of Khansā took from me. He answered: This garment was made for me by my brother Jalāl Oddīn, for my own use, who also wrote to me to say that the garment would come to me by such a person. He then produced the letter, which I read, and could not help wondering at the exactness of the Sheikh. I then told him of the origin of the story. He answered, My brother Jalāl Oddīn was superior to all this : he had a perfect control over human nature; 3 but now he has been taken to God’s mercy. He then said, I have been told, that he performed the morning prayer every day in Mecca; that he went on the pilgrimage annually, because he was never to be seen on the two days of bArafat and the feast, no one knowing whither he had gone.

When, however, I had bid farewell to the Sheikh Jalāl Oddīn, I travelled to the city of cJabnak, which is very large and beautiful; it is divided by the river which descends from the mountains of Kāmrū, called the dBlue River. By this one may travel to Bengal and the countries of eLaknoutī.

Footnote References:
1 The name of this place is variously written; in some cases we have Sutirkāwān, in others according to our MSS. In the we have and It was, no doubt, the name of a place then in Bengal; but whether it is still in existence or not the geographers do not inform us. We are told, in the author just mentioned, that Mohammed Shah made an expedition, in A.H. 741, A.D. 1340, to this place, and took Fakhr Oddīn, the king mentioned by our traveller, prisoner, carried him to Laknoutl, and there put him to death”[30].

6. Literature:

Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century, Updated With A 2012 Preface, University of California Press, 2012, First Paperback Printing 1989. ISBN 978-0-520-27292-7[31].

Finds:
“Ibn Battuta seems to have wanted to visit the delta in the summer of 1345 mainly to seek the blessing of Shah Jalal. He was a celebrated holy warrior who, in the year our traveler was born, participated in the Muslim takeover of Sylhet, a town and district in the northeastern corner of the delta.22 Under normal circumstances, Ibn Battuta would also have had himself presented at the princely court of Fakhr al-Din, whose capital was at Sonargaon, a city about half way along the route from the coast to Sylhet. In this case, however, Fakhr al-Din’s dissidence was too recent and his own identification with Muhammad Tughluq too well known to make such an introduction advisable. Consequently, he decided to steer clear of royal interviews and make a quick trip up to Sylhet as anonymously as possible.

He probably disembarked at the busy eastern port of Chittagong, a city overflowing with agricultural goods transported by river craft down through the maze of delta channels to the coast.23 He notes in the Rihla that foreigners liked to call Bengal “a hell crammed with good things.” The noxious, humid vapours exuded from the delta’s marshes and riverbanks made for an oppressive climate, but food was abundant and remarkably cheap. To prove his point, he even offers in the Rihla a list of prices for rice, meat, fowl, sugar, oil, cotton, and slaves. Not to pass up a bargain himself, he purchased an 

“extremely beautiful” slave girl in Chittagong. One of his comrades acquired a young boy for “a couple of gold dinars.[32]”

“He tells us nothing very lucid about the itinerary or time schedule of his trip from Chittagong to Sylhet, but he very likely traveled by boat northward along the Meghna River valley, a lush, watery, rice-growing country leading to the Assam Plateau and the Tibetan Himalayas beyond.24 He seems to have had a party of companions, but they are more phantom-like than ever. Al-Tuzari was apparently with him when he visited Ma’bar, but he is never mentioned after that and indeed we learn parenthetically in an earlier part of the Rihla that the man died in India.25

Shah Jalal of Sylhet, whose tomb is still a local pilgrimage center, was renowned in medieval India for awesome miracles, prognostications, and the feat of dying at the age of 150.26 One day, the Rihla reports, the old shaykh, who had no previous knowledge of Ibn Battuta, told his disciples that a traveler from the Maghrib was about to arrive and that they should go out to meet him. This they did, intercepting the visitor two days’ distance from the khanqah. The story gives Ibn Battuta a convenient entrée to remind his readers of his own singular accomplishments as a globetrotter:

When I visited him he rose to receive me and embraced me. He enquired of me about my country and journeys, of which I gave him an account. He said to me, “You are a traveler of Arabia.” His disciples who were then present said, “O lord, he is also a traveler of the non-Arab countries.[33]” “Traveler of the non-Arab countries!” rejoined the shaykh, “Treat him, then, with favor.” Therefore they took me to the hospice and entertained me for three days.

Returning southward along the Meghna River past “water wheels, gardens, and villages such as those along the banks of the Nile in Egypt,” he reached Sonargaon (not far from modern Dacca), the capital of Sultan Fakr al-Din. Without dallying long or identifying himself at the royal residence, he bought passage on a commercial junk departing down the river and went directly on to Sumatra”[34].

Footnotes:
“22. N. K. Bhattasali, Coins and Chronology of the Early Independent Sultans of Bengal (Cambridge, England, 1922; reprint edn., New Delhi, 1976), pp. 150–54.

23. IB identifies the place of his debarkation as Sudkawan. Several historians have taken sides on the issue of whether this toponym corresponds to Chittagong, today an important city in southeastern Bangladesh, or Satgaon, a medieval commercial center in the western delta region north of modern Calcutta. The proponents of Chittagong are Muhammad Abdur Rahim, Social and Cultural History of Bengal (Karachi, 1963), pp. 12–14; Bhattasali, Coins and Chronology, pp. 145–49; Gibb, Travels in Asia and Africa, p. 366n; MH, p. 235n; and Yule, Cathay, vol. 4, p. 82n. The advocates of Satgaon are Jadunath Sarkar (ed.), The History of Bengal, 2 vols. (Dacca, 1948), vol. 2, p. 100; Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal, trans. Harinath De, and ed. P. N. Ghosh (Calcutta, 1978), app. I, pp. 1–4; Ferrand, Relations de voyages, pp. 434–35; and Henri Cordier, editor of 3rd edn. of Yule’s Cathay, vol. 4, p. 82n. Without laying out the several semantic and geographical arguments advanced on both sides, I find the case for Chittagong the more convincing, especially in the context of IB’s subsequent movements through Bengal.

24. IB states that he went to see Shah Jalal in the mountains of Kamaru, that is, Kamrup in Assam. Sylhet, however, is on the edge of the delta region just south of the hills of Assam. IB does not mention Sylhet by name, but Shah Jalal is known to have resided there. Yule, Cathay, vol. 4, pp. 151–52. Mahdi Husain[35] (MH, p. 237n) suggests that IB made a long looping tour up the Brahmaputra River through central Assam, then southward to Sylhet. But there is nothing in IB’s account of his personal experiences indicating he went any further north than Sylhet.

25. In connection with his befriending al-Tuzari in Cairo, IB states that the man “continued to accompany me for many years, until we quitted the land of India, when he died at Sandabur.” Gb, vol. 2, p. 415. However, IB says nothing of al-Tuzari in the account of his experiences at Sandapur, and the man was apparently still in his suite later in Ma’bar. It is conceivable that IB made a subsequent visit to Sandapur that he never mentions in the Rihla and left al-Tuzari there; or else al-Tuzari went there on his own when IB left India on his way to China.

26. IB calls the man he visited Shaykh Jalal al-Din al-Tabrizi, but he appears to have confused the saint of this name, a divine of the Suhrawardi order who died about 1225, with Shah Jalal, the Muslim conqueror of Sylhet. Abdul Karim, Social History of the Muslims of Bengal (Dacca, 1959), pp. 91–101; Abdur Rahim, Social and Cultural History of Bengal, pp. 85–103; Bhattasali, Coins and Chronology, pp. 149–54. This mistake might raise questions about the authenticity of IB’s journey into the interior of Bengal, except that Bengalis themselves commonly confuse these two holy men and even use “Shah Jalal” as a generic term for any powerful saint. Personal communication from Richard Eaton, University of Arizona”[36].

7. Literature:
Social History of the Muslims in Bengal (Down To A. D. 1538) Abdul Karim Ma Ph.D. (Dacca). Published by The Asiatic Society of Pakistan, Dacca. East Pakistan, 1959.

Bibliography:

1.      Shah Jalal (R), Banglapedia entry - the National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh, http://en.banglapedia.org/index.php?title=Shah_Jalal_(R), accessed on 28.09.2017, “(T)his page was last modified on 7 April 2015, at 12:45”.
2.      Persian inscription of 918 AH/1512 AD issued in the reign of Sultan Alauddin husain shah (1494-1519 AD).
3.      Ghausi's Persian Gulzar-i-abrar: biographies of mystics & learned men, written in 1613 AD. Muhammad Ghausi ibn Hasan ibn Musa Shattari (d. AD 1617)
4.      Sharh-i-Nuzhat-ul-Arwah by Shaikh Ali Sher, a descendant of Shaikh Nurul Huda Abul Karamat, who was a companion of Shah Jalal (R).
5.      Suhail-i-Yaman, Nasiruddin Haidar, a biography of Shah Jalal (R) in Persian, 1860.
6.      Risalat written by Muhiuddim Khadim in 1711 AD. Manuscript was kept preserved in the dargah of the saint.
7.      Rauzat-us-Salatin written by an unknown author in 1721 AD. Manuscript was kept preserved in the dargah of the saint.
8.      HAR Gibb, Ibn Battuta: Travels in Asia and Africa, London 1928.
9.      Journal of the Asiatic Society of Pakistan, II, 1959;
10.   ME Haq, A History of Sufism in Bengal, Dhaka 1975;
11.   Shah Jalal, Wikipedia entry, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Jalal,[37] accessed on 28.09.2017. Wikipedia cautioned that “(T)his article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources. (August 2009)”, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Jalal, accessed on 28.09.2017.
12.   Tablet inscription found in Amberkhana, (Ahmed, Shamsuddin, Inscription of Bengal, vol. iv, Dhaka (1960), p 25).
13.   A Karim, Social History of the Muslim in Bengal, (2nd ed), Chittagong 1985.
14.   Ahmed, Shamsuddin, Inscription of Bengal, vol. iv, Dhaka (1960).
15.   Eaton, Richard M. (1993). The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204–1760 (PDF). Berkeley: University of California Press.
16.    Rahman, M. F., Hazrat Shah Jalal and 360 Awliya, Deshkaal Publications, Sylhet, 1992, p.12-13
17.    Islam in South Asia in practice source of shuhel-e-yamani By Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published by – Princeton universiti press, 2009. Page 385 [1]
18.   Karim, Abdul (2012). "Shah Jalal (R)". In Islam, Sirajul; Jamal, Ahmed A. Banglapedia: National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh (Second ed.). Asiatic Society of Bangladesh.
19.    Hazrat Shah Jalal O Sylhet er Itihas by Syed Mujtaba Ali, re-published by Utsa Prakashan, Dhaka, 1988, p.60
20.    Rihla 9, 1344
21.    Islam in South Asia in practice By – Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published – Princeton university press Uk 2009, Page 383 – 385.
22.    The rise of Islam and the Bengal frontier, 1204–1760, By Richard Maxwell Eaton, Published by – university of california press, page 76
23.    Rahman, M. F., Hazrat Shah Jalal and 360 Awliya, p.13, Deshkaal Publications, Sylhet, 1992
24.    Ziaul Haque, Md., Hazrat Shah Jalal (R.A): An Epic, p.114, Choitonno Publication, Sylhet, 2015
25.   Systems, Cognitive (2012-04-08). "The seven golden chains of Shaykh Muhammad Siraj ad-Din Naqshbandi (d.1915)". Ghaffari. Retrieved 2017-07-09.
26.   Islam in South Asia in practice, By Barbara Daly Metcalf, Published by Princeton universiti press.
27.   Shaykh Shah Jalal, http://www.haqislam.org/biographies/shah-jalal.htm, accessed on 28.09.2017.
28.   N. K. Bhattasali, Coins and Chronology of the Early Independent Sultans of Bengal (Cambridge, England, 1922; reprint edn., New Delhi, 1976), pp. 150–54.
29.   Agha Mahdi Husain (trans. and ed.). The Rehla of Ibn Battuta (Baroda, India, 1976), available at: https://archive.org/details/TheRehlaOfIbnBattuta
30.   Abdul Karim, Social History of the Muslims of Bengal (Dacca, 1959), pp. 91–101;
31.   Abdur Rahim, Social and Cultural History of Bengal, pp. 85–103; https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.98074/2015.98074.Social-And-Cultural-History-Of-Bengal-Vol-1_djvu.txt
32.   Bhattasali, Coins and Chronology, pp. 149–54.
33.   Amir Khusrau, Afdalul Hawaade
34.   Muhammad Mojlum Khan, The Muslim Heritage of Bengal: The Lives, Thoughts and Achievements of Great Muslim Scholars, Writers and Reformers of Bangladesh and West Bengal, Kube Publishing Ltd, 2013, Google Book version: https://goo.gl/hYYuAM
35.   Tarikhe Jalali তারিখে জালালি, মৌলবি নাসির উদ্দিন হায়দার, মোস্তাক আহমাদ দীন (Translator) Publisher, Utsho Prokashon, July 2008. Rokomari.com
36.   সৈয়দ মোস্তফা কামাল, হযরত শাহ জালাল (রহ); কারামতঃ ৩৬০ আউলিয়া (৩১ তম সংস্করণ) ২০০৬ খ্রিঃ। প্রকাশক- শেখ ফারুক আহমদ, পলাশ সেবা ট্রাস্ট সিলেট, প্রকাশকাল- ফেব্রুয়ারি ২০১১.
37.   দেওয়ান নুরুল আনওয়ার জালালাবাদের কথা, বাংলা একাডেমি
38.   মতিয়ার রহমান চৌধুরী, 'সিলেট বিভাগের ইতিবৃত্ত'
39.   মোহাম্মদ মুমিনুল হক, 'সিলেট বিভাগের ইতিবৃত্ত’, গতিধারা
40.   হজরত শাহ্‌ জালাল ও সিলেটের ইতিহাস, সৈয়দ মুর্তাজা আলী; প্রথম প্রকাশ ১৯৬৫; উৎস প্রকাশন; উৎস সংস্করণ: জুলাই ২০০৩। Rokomari.com
41.  শ্রীহট্টের ইতিবৃত্ত (পূর্বাংশ), অচ্যুতচরণ চৌধুরী তত্ত্বনিধি. উৎস প্রকাশন
42.  শ্রীহট্টের ইতিবৃত্ত (উত্তরাংশ), অচ্যুতচরণ চৌধুরী তত্ত্বনিধি, উৎস প্রকাশন, https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.265080
“১,৬৬৩ পৃষ্ঠার এই ইতিহাস গ্রন্থটি দুইটি আলাদা আলাদা খণ্ডে প্রকাশিত হয়। এর মধ্যে শ্রীহট্টের ইতিবৃত্ত (পূর্বাংশ) (৭৭৯ পৃষ্ঠা) প্রকাশিত হয় ১৩১৭ বঙ্গাব্দে (১৯১০ খ্রিস্টাব্দ) এবং শ্রীহট্টের ইতিবৃত্ত (উত্তরাংশ) (৮৮৪) প্রকাশিত হয় ১৩২৪ বঙ্গাব্দে (১৯১৭ খ্রিস্টাব্দ)। গ্রন্থটি প্রকাশের জন্য কামরূপ শাসনাবলীর গ্রন্থকার পণ্ডিত পদ্মনাথ ভট্টাচার্য তৎকালীন মূল্যমানের সাড়ে চার হাজার টাকা অনুদান দিয়েছিলেন। প্রকাশিত গ্রন্থটি সম্পর্কে চট্টগ্রামের ঐতিহাসিক আবদুল হক চৌধুরীর অভিমত: সংগৃহীত উপাদানের সাহায্যে তাঁর আগে এতবড় ইতিহাস গ্রন্থ এদেশে (বাংলাদেশে) কেউ লিখেননি। এই বৃহৎ বইটিতে তিনি সিলেটের ঐতিহাসিক ও প্রাকৃতিক বিবরণ ছাড়াও প্রতিটি গ্রামের প্রাচীন হিন্দু-মুসলমান পরিবারগুলোর ইতিহাস, কবি, রাজনীতিবিদ, ফকির-দরবেশ, সাধু, আওলিয়াদের সংক্ষিপ্ত জীবনী লিখে গেছেন। এছাড়া দিয়েছেন বহু ঐতিহাসিক সনদ, প্রাচীন মুদ্রা ও ফরমানের আলোকচিত্র, বংশলতিকার অনুলিপি ও প্রাচীন মুদ্রার ছবি।
মূল গ্রন্থ দুটির প্রকাশক ছিলেন কলকাতার শ্রী উপেন্দ্র নাথ পাল চৌধুরী, আর মূল্য ছিল যথাক্রমে তৎকালীন মূল্যে মাত্র চার টাকা ও পাঁচ টাকা।[১] বইটি দীর্ঘদিন আর পুণর্মুদ্রিত না হলেও পরবর্তিতে বাংলাদেশের উৎস প্রকাশন তা পুণর্মুদ্রণের উদ্যোগ নেয়, যদিও তাতে কোনো সংশোধন না এনে মূলের অণুবর্তী রাখার চেষ্টা লক্ষ করা যায়।[তথ্যসূত্র প্রয়োজন] এছাড়াও কলকাতা থেকেও বইটির দুটি খণ্ড পুণর্মুদ্রিত হয়েছে।[৩]“
43.  সিলেটের ইতিহাস প্রসঙ্গ, আবদুল হক চৌধুরী; কথামালা প্রকাশনা, চট্টগ্রাম থেকে মুদ্রিত: জুলাই ১৯৯৩.
44.  হজরত শাহ্‌ জালাল ও সিলেটের ইতিহাস, সৈয়দ মুর্তাজা আলী; উৎস প্রকাশন, ঢাকা থেকে পুণর্মুদ্রিত: জুলাই ২০০৩
45.  Muslim Banglar Samajik Itihas (মোছলেম বঙ্গের সামাজিক ইতিহাস) -আকরম খাঁ ১৯৫৬, ঐতিহ্য
46.  Ahmad, Mufti Azharuddin, History of Shah Jalal and His Khadims. Sylhet, 1914.
47.  Bangladeshi Sufis: Shah Jalal, Shah Paran, Shah Sultan Balkhi Mahisawar, Sureswar Darbar Sharif, Saheb Qibla Fultali, LLC Books, Publisher            General Books LLC, 2010. Google Books.
48.  Biographical Encyclopaedia of Sufis: South Asia, By N. Hanif, Sarup & Sons, 2000 - Sufis - 403 pages, Google Book.
49.  Dealing with Deities: The Ritual Vow in South Asia, edited by Selva J. Raj, William P. Harman, SUNY Press, 2012 - Religion - 288 pages, Google Book.
50.  Islam in South Asia in Practice, edited by Barbara D. Metcalf, Princeton University Press, 2009, Google Books.
51.  Muslim Saints of South Asia: The Eleventh to Fifteenth Centuries, By Anna Suvorova, Professor of Indo-Islamic Culture and Head of Department of Asian Literatures Anna Suvorova, Routledge, 2004, Google Books.
52.  Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism, and Slavery, By M. A. Khan. iUniverse, 2009. Google Books.
53.  Untaming the Frontier in Anthropology, Archaeology, and History, edited by Bradley J. Parker, Lars Rodseth, University of Arizona Press, 2005 - Business & Economics - 294 pages, Google Books.
54.  The Bangladesh Reader: History, Culture, Politics, By Meghna Guhathakurta, Willem van Schendel, Duke University Press, Apr 30, 2013 - History - 550 pages, Google Books.
55.  HSJ Mazaar Sharif, By Mayar Akash, Lulu.com, Mar 24, 2017, Google Books.
56.  Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, Volume 42, Asiatic Society, 1873. Google Books; biodiversitylibrary.org; archive.org; pahar.in Part 1 & Part 2;
57.  Historical Dictionary of the Bengalis, By Kunal Chakrabarti, Shubhra Chakrabarti, Scarecrow Press, Aug 22, 2013 - History - 604 pages, Google Books.
58.  Sultans and Mosques: The Early Muslim Architecture of Bangladesh, By Perween Hasan, I.B.Tauris, Aug 15, 2007 - Architecture - 241 pages, Google Books.
59.  Sufism and Saint Veneration in Contemporary Bangladesh: The Maijbhandaris of Chittagong, Hans Harder, Routledge, Mar 8, 2011 - Religion - 392 pages, Google Books.
60.  The Bengal Diaspora: Rethinking Muslim Migration, By Claire Alexander, Joya Chatterji, Annu Jalais, Routledge, Nov 6, 2015 - History - 304 pages, Google Books.
61.  Hazrat Shahjalal (R:) o tin so shat awlia, Muhammed Faizur Rahman, Deshkal, 1992. 88 pages.
62.  Sufi Movements in Eastern India, Mohammad Yahya Tamizi, Idarah-i Adabiyat-i Delli, 1992 - Mysticism - 199 pages
63.  The New Province of Eastern Bengal & Assam, 1905-1911, M. K. U. Molla, Institute of Bangladesh Studies, Rajshahi University, 1981 - Eastern Bengal and Assam (India) - 272 pages.
64.  Sufis of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, Volume 2, Kitab Bhavan, 2002 - Sufis - 263 pages.
65.  Islam in Bangladesh, edited by U. A. B. Razia Akter Banu, U. A. B. Razia Akter Banu, BRILL, 1992 - Religion - 194 pages.
66.  Sylhet: History and Heritage, Bangladesh Itihas Samiti, Jan 1, 1999 - Sylhet District (Bangladesh) - 986 pages.
67.  History of Bengal, Part 1, Sushila Mondal, Prakash Mandir, 1970 - Bengal (India).
68.  Sufis of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, Volume 3, Kitab Bhavan, 2002 - Sufis - 264 pages.
69.  Journal of the Pakistan Historical Society, Volumes 7-8, Pakistan Historical Society., 1959 – Pakistan.
70.  The Pakistan Review, Volume 3, Ferozsons Limited, 1955 – Pakistan.
71.  Encyclopaedia of Muslim Biography: I-M, Nagendra Kr Singh, A.P.H. Publishing Corporation, 2001 - Bangladesh - 622 pages.
72.  The Islamic heritage of Bengal, Page 49, George Michell, Unesco, 1984 - Architecture - 239 pages.
73.  Population Census of Bangladesh, 1974: District census report, Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistics Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, 1979 – Bangladesh.
74.  Saints of East Pakistan, Syed Murtaza Ali, Oxford University Press, Pakistan Branch, 1971 - Muslim saints - 61 pages.
75.  Short Notes on the Ancient Monuments of Gaur and Panduah, M. ʻĀbid ʻAlī Khān, publisher not identified, 1913 - Architecture - 62 pages.
76.  Epigraphy and Islamic Culture: Inscriptions of the Early Muslim Rulers of Bengal (1205-1494), Mohammad Yusuf Siddiq, Routledge, Nov 19, 2015 - ARCHITECTURE - 298 pages, Google Books.
77.  Firminger, Walter K (ed), Sylhet district records: Vol 2 1786-1788 [ie 1787]. Shillong, 1913-17, Archive.org.
78.  Assam District Gazetteers (sylhet) Vol. 2, by Allen, B. C., Publication date 1905, archive.org.
79.  Assam District Gazetteers-sylhet Supplement To Vol. 2, Publication date 1915, archive.org.
80.  Rajmala. http://www.tripura.org.in/rajmala.htm; The Rajmala Vol Iii: archive.org
The Rajmala is the royal chronicle of Tripura kings that ruled for about five thousand years since the mythological prehistoric times. So called historically, the period of the royal dynasty is three thousand years old. The Tripuri people in general believe that they & the royal dynasties of Tripura were descendant of Chandra Vamsha. Historically it can be proved that the Chandra dynasty was basically of Kirata origin, which is ethnologically known as Indo-Mongoloid people. They were among the first to come in India, in the prehistoric time around 8000 BC, through the Khyber Pass, north west of Indian Subcontinent. This human ethnic group then settled first in the Indus Valley region, founded the Indus civilisation along with some other human groups and latter spread all over India. This fact can be substantiated by a Mongoloid race skull discovered in the Mohenjo-daro excavation, and a terracotta figurine of Mongoloid look. 
“The list of all the kings and their stories were passed down orally through the Chantai, the Royal priest of Tripura from generation to generation, like the Veda used to be memorized by Brahmins and passed down generation by generation. The Chantai was the head and royal priest and still worshiping the fourteen gods, which are the Kula Devata of Tripuri people and the dynasty. The earlier Rajmala was composed in Sanskrit as "RAJRATNAKARAM". As per the records of Rajmala, it was originally written in Tripuri language, by Chantai Durlabhendra, which was later on translated in Sanskrit and Bengali. It was considered as one of the earliest Bengali literature. The Rajmala has four volume, written at different time and by different author. Many scholars had studied the book and most of independent and neutral researchers and experts have described as authentic, true and historically valuable”. http://www.tripura.org.in/rajmala.htm
“(Bengali: রাজমালা) is a chronicle of the Kings of Tripura, written in Bengali verse in the 15th century under Dharma Manikya. Reportedly, the Bengali version was composed by the pandits Sukreshwar and Baneshwar of the royal court based on the recitations by the royal priest Dhurlabhendra Chantai of an oral tradition in the Tripuri language”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rajmala.
81.  শ্রীহট্টের ইতিবৃত্ত পূর্বাংশ, দ্বিতীয় ভাগ, দ্বিতীয় খণ্ড, দ্বিতীয় অধ্যায়, দরবেশ শাহজালাল অচ্যুতচরণ চৌধুরী তত্ত্বনিধি, প্রকাশক: মোস্তফা সেলিম; উৎস প্রকাশন, ২০০৪।

Characters to Explore:

  1. The king of Bengal Fakhr Oddīn, or Fakhr al-Din;
  2. El Mostaasim the Calif in Bagdad;
  3. Borhān Oddīn of Sāgirj;
  4. Hindu king named Gaur Govinda ruled the Sylhet area;
  5. Sultan shamsuddin firuz shah;
  6. Sultan shamsuddin firuz shah’s nephew Sikandar Khan Ghazi, or Sikandar Shah Ghazi
  7. Sultan shamsuddin firuz shah’s sipahxalar (armed forces chief) Nasiruddin;
  8. ibn batuta visited Bengal when Sultan fakhruddin mubarak shah was ruling at Sonargaon (1338-1349 AD).
  9. Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi (R);
  10. Persian inscription of 918 AH/1512 AD issued in the reign of Sultan Alauddin husain shah (1494-1519 AD).
  11. Shaikh Jalal Mujarrad ibn Muhammad (Formal name of Hazrat Shah Jalal (R));
  12. Shaikh-ul-Mashaikh Makhdum Shaikh Jalal Mujarrad bin Muhammad (another Formal name of Hazrat Shah Jalal (R))
  13. Shaikh Nurul Huda Abul Karamat;
  14. Sultan Syed Ahmed Yesvi, Pir of Shaikh Jalal Mujarrad;
  15. Hazrat Shah Jalal (R)'s father, Muhammad, a sufi of Yamen;
  16. Hazrat Shah Jalal (R)'s maternal uncle Sayyid Ahamd Kabir Suhrawardy, a great saint; or maternal uncle Syed Ahmed Kabir in Mecca;
  17. Hazrat Shah Jalal (R) met Shakh Nizamuddin Auliya at Delhi;
  18. Shaikh 'Ali (d. 1562), a descendant of one of Shah Jalal's companions;
  19. he became a spiritual disciple of Saiyid Ahmad Yasawi, one of the founders of the Central Asian Sufi tradition;
  20. Hazrat Shah Jalal (R)'s mother, Syeda Hasina Fatimah,
  21. Hazrat Shah Jalal (R)'s father, Mahmoud bin Mohammed bin Ibrahim;
  22. Amir Khusrau also gives an account of Shah Jalal's conquest of Sylhet in his book Afdalul Hawaade;
  23.  

To Do/ Explore:

1.      Look in to Mirza Nathan’s Bahristan I Gayebi;
2.      Rajmala, History of Tripura Royal family;
3.      History of Assam;
4.      Explore each character found in the available history.
5.      Social and Cultural History of Bengal, Volume 1, Issue 34 of Pakistan Historical Society publication, Social and Cultural History of Bengal, Muhammad Abdur Rahim, Author             Muhammad Abdur Rahim, Publisher: Pakistan Historical Society, 1963. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]
6.      Khan, Abdul Majed. “The Historicity of Ibn Batuta Re. Sham-Suddin Firuz Shah, the So-Called Balbani King of Bengal.” Indian Historical Quarterly 18 (1942): 65–70. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]
7.      De, Harinath (trans.), and Ghosh, P. N. (ed.). Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal. Calcutta, 1978. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]
8.      Bhattasali, N. K. Coins and Chronology of the Early Independent Sultans of Bengal. With Translation of “Ibn-Batuta’s Travels in Bengal” from French by S. N. Bose. Cambridge, England, 1922; reprint edn., New Delhi, 1976. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]. Full text available at: https://archive.org/details/coinschronologyo00bhatuoft
9.      Karim, Abdul. Social History of the Muslims in Bengal. Dacca, 1959. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]
10.   Sarkar, Jadunath (ed.). The History of Bengal. 2 vols. Vol. 2: Muslim Period 1200–1757. Dacca, 1948. [for Ibn Batutah’s Account of Bengal]
11.   In 1994, the Hakluyt Society published the fourth and final volume of the English translation of the Rihla, bringing to conclusion a project that began in 1929.
12.   “He was a celebrated holy warrior who, in the year our traveler was born, participated in the Muslim takeover of Sylhet”. What year?



[14] Wikipedia cautioned that “(T)his article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources. (August 2009)”, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Jalal, accessed on 28.09.2017.
[17] “(h)e arrived at Sylhet in 1303 CE” and biographer Shaikh 'Ali is dated (d. 1562), so how there is a gap of “several” centuries? It can only be two centuries. Several means more than two, author.
[25] “The present work on Ibn Battuta’s odyssey has, of necessity, a more modest aim. Like an abridged translation, the material presented here has had to be selective”, Waines, David, The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta - Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer, I.B.Tauris & Co. Ltd 2010, Preface and Acknowledgements, Page ix.
[26] Waines, David, The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta - Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer, I.B.Tauris & Co. Ltd 2010, Preface and Acknowledgements, Page 61.
[27] Waines, David, The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta - Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer, I.B.Tauris & Co. Ltd 2010, Preface and Acknowledgements, Page 61.
[28] Waines, David, The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta - Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer, I.B.Tauris & Co. Ltd 2010, Preface and Acknowledgements, Page 137, 138.
[29] The Vizier of Maldive Islands, CHAPTER XXI, Ibn Batuta, 1304–1377, [Tuhfat al-nuzzar fi ghara'ib al-amsar wa-'aja'ib al-asfar, English, Selections], The travels of Ibn Battuta in the Near East, Asia and Africa 1325–1354; Translated From The Abridged Arabic Manuscript Copies, Preserved In The Public Library Of Cambridge, translated and edited by Samuel Lee. Originally published: London: Oriental Translation Committee, 1829. Bibliographical Note -This Dover edition, first published in 2004, is an unabridged republication of The Travels of Ibn Batūta, translated from the Abridged Arabic Manuscript Copies and preserved in the Public Library of Cambridge, first printed by The Oriental Translation Committee, London, in 1829. DOVER PUBLICATIONS, INC., Mineola, New York.
[30] CHAPTER XXI, The travels of Ibn Battuta in the Near East, Asia and Africa 1325–1354. Translated and edited by Samuel Lee, ibid.
[31] “Indeed, this book, part biography and part cultural history of the second quarter of the fourteenth century, is a work of synthesis. In tracing Ibn Battuta’s footsteps through the equivalent of some 44 modern countries, I have relied on a wide range of published literature”, “I have used printed Arabic editions of the Rihla to clarify various problems of nomenclature and textual meaning, but I have largely depended on the major English or French translations in relating and interpreting Ibn Battuta’s career”, Unless otherwise noted, quotations are taken from the published translations as follows: Chapters 1–8 and 14, H. A. R. Gibb, The Travels of Ibn Battuta A.D. 1325–1354, 3 vols.; Chapters 9–11, Agha Mahdi Husain, The Rehla of Ibn Battuta; and Chapter 13, N. Levtzion and J. F. P. Hopkins (eds.), Corpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History”, Preface to the First Edition,
[32] Chapter 11 China, Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century, Updated With A 2012 Preface, University of California Press, 2012, First Paperback Printing 1989. ISBN 978-0-520-27292-7.
[33] Chapter 11 China, Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century, ibid.
[34] Chapter 11 China, Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century,, ibid.
[35] Agha Mahdi Husain (trans. and ed.). The Rehla of Ibn Battuta (Baroda, India, 1976), Abbreviations Used in Footnotes, Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century,, ibid.
[36] Chapter 11 China, Dunn, Ross E., The Adventures of Ibn Battuta, A Muslim Traveler of the 14th Century, ibid.
[37] Wikipedia cautioned that “(T)his article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources. (August 2009)”, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Jalal, accessed on 28.09.2017.